Seemingly unusable and somewhat unloved,
one of New York's most arresting works of 1960's Brutalist architecture
— a forceful, concrete-clad evocation of Le Corbusier — is about to be
demolished.
Now empty, the 35-year-old building at 217
East 87th Street served until last year as the 40-bed nonsectarian Youth
Residence Center. It was built and operated by the Jewish Child Care
Association.
The center is to be replaced by one of
three chapels being developed in Manhattan by the Church of Jesus Christ
of Latter-day Saints, which looked at reusing the existing structure at
the request of preservationists but concluded that would be impossible.
"It was a dormitory and just didn't
fit our needs," explained Scott Trotter, the public affairs manager
for the church. The chapel, designed by Frank Fernandez, will have a
sanctuary, classrooms and a cultural hall for sports, dances, religious
meetings or overflow from worship services. The exterior, Mr. Trotter
said, will be a traditional ecclesiastical design, with stained-glass
windows. It will serve some 500 Mormons who live between 50th and 110th
Streets, Fifth Avenue and the East River, and now attend services at
Columbus Avenue and 65th Street. Demolition is to begin imminently, Mr.
Trotter said, and construction will take 18 months. As a matter of policy,
the church does not discuss project costs.
Horace Ginsbern & Associates designed
the youth center. Although it is neither a landmark nor among the
best-known works of modernism, it has admirers like the preservation
groups Friends of the Upper East Side Historic
Districts and Docomomo. And it is possible — even now — to
see why.
Like Corbusier's monastery of La Tourette
in France or City Hall in Boston, it erupts from the ground in a top-heavy
explosion of Cubist concrete forms, creating a stunning play of light and
shadow. Yet it keeps a civil tone. "This building does manage to do
what Brutalism often fails at, which is to work comfortably with its
neighbors," Paul Goldberger wrote in 1979 in "The City Observed:
New York."
Over the years, the center housed some
1,400 youths. "Not only was the program too expensive but
contemporary child care practice encourages community-based
facilities," said Jane Barowitz, communications director for the
Jewish Child Care Association, contrasting the East Side building with the
agency's new foster-care center at Bergen Avenue and 149th Street in the
Bronx.
Richard Collrossi, a neighbor on 87th
Street, said he was relieved that the center had closed, since occupants
badgered passers-by. "I believe in live and let live," he said,
"but they bothered people." As for the prospect of its being
replaced by a chapel? "I love it," he said.
|