New York’s exhibit for the
Fair was conceived as “The County Fair of the Future.” Of course this
was to be America’s “Space Age” World’s Fair and everyone seemed
to be touting “TOMORROW” in one form or another. Johnson’s structure
was no exception with the design being reminiscent of something out of a
Jetsons' comic book. The pavilion consists of three principal structures:
the circular Theaterama building, the “Tent of Tomorrow” and three
observation towers, the highest at 226 feet, providing Fairgoers with a
panoramic view of the grounds.
The “Tent of Tomorrow” was the heart of
Johnson’s pavilion. An elliptical shaped, 350-foot by 250-foot
structure, whose outer support of sixteen 100-foot tall, white concrete
columns, made it one of the largest buildings at the Fair. The Tent
featured the world's largest suspension roof. And on the floor, the
world’s largest road map - the State of New York done in terrazzo. After
all, this was Nelson Rockefeller’s New York State Pavilion showcasing
his state. Everything was required to be the tallest, the largest and the
best.
The pavilion is completely open save for the first
two floors topped by a mezzanine walkway. The suspension roof made of
translucent fiberglass panels done to resemble stained glass kept out some
of the elements. But the building, for all practical purposes, is a
12-story high open-air structure.
Construction for the pavilion began in October,
1962. One of the first steps in the construction process for all pavilions
was to call in the pile drivers. To build something of any size on the
site required 18-inch wooden piles to be driven into the marshy ground for
building support. Picture huge telephone poles lined up in rows at the
sites of construction. Some contractors working on site reported that some
of their piles simply disappeared as they were driven into the ground, so
unstable was the ground these buildings were being built on.
No matter. The Fair was temporary - meant to last
only two years. Wooden piles were surely good enough for such a short time
frame. Moses was building his Fair with an eye to the future and had
already decided that structures built for the Fair that did not have
useful post-Fair park purposes would have no place in the post-Fair park.
So all exhibitors signed the same lease that said their pavilions were to
be demolished within 90 days of the close of the Fair in October, 1965.
The New York State World’s Fair Commission no doubt signed that lease as
well.
But somewhere in the early construction phase,
someone had an inkling that this building might serve a useful park
purpose someday. Or maybe someone realized that the taxpayers of New York
would be footing a pretty big bill to construct such a structure for the
Fair. Perhaps they would not be too happy to see all of those tax dollars
reduced to rubble after two short years. The Landmark Preservation
Commission in 1995 noted that it stayed because it was too expensive to
tear down. Whatever the reason, it is believed that steel piles were
driven into the ground to support the New York State Pavilion along with
the wooden piles. However, their exact location was never documented.
The two years of the Fair came and went. Johnson’s
design was praised for its innovation and simple sophistication; winning
an “Honorable Mention” award for Excellence in Design by the New York
Chapter of the AIA. Photos of the pavilion during the Fair show a colorful
structure that was popular with the crowds and served its exhibit purpose
well. Nighttime shots of the pavilion show how spectacular illumination
made the pavilion seem almost cathedral-like as lighting suspended from
cables above the translucent roof created a dazzling stained glass effect.
In the summer of 1965, a special commission
established by New York’s Mayor Robert Wagner submitted a list of
pavilions they thought should remain to serve the park. Among them was
Johnson’s New York State Pavilion. The Commission felt the towers
constituted a natural tourist attraction. The Theaterama building would be
a great marrionette theater and the “Tent of Tomorrow” could provide a
covered area for athletic events, concerts and dancing. Robert Moses
thought it would make a good “art museum.” So it stayed while the rest
of the Fair went away.
Money was eventually spent to refurbish parts of the
pavilion to display art. And for a brief period following the Fair, there
were a few art exhibits shown. The Byrds played a concert there once. So
did the Grateful Dead. From 1970 to 1974, a roller rink operator from Ohio
operated the pavilion as a popular outdoor roller skating rink called the
Roller Round. The million dollar terrazzo map was plastic coated to
protect the surface from the skaters. Talk was that the World Trade
Center, then under construction, would be interested in having the map as
a part of their grand courtyard. But it never happened. The floor stayed.
The towers were never opened.
In the early years, Park inspectors paid close
attention to the pavilion coming around every so often to inspect the roof
and the floor and the building in general. Security patrols regularly
followed a beat and the Park stayed a place for recreation and fun. But
after 1974, things started to change for the Pavilion, the Park and the
City of New York. The Roller Round closed after a dispute over who was
responsible for maintenance forced the rink operator to suspend operations
and the pavilion sat empty once again. The great financial crisis of the
mid-seventies hit the Park with a vengeance. The city was broke. There was
no money for many things, but especially not parks.
Gone were the inspections. Gone were the funds for
maintenance and improvements and security patrols. And gone were ideas for
finding a useful purpose for Johnson’s pavilion. The open-air concept
that had been called so innovative for a World’s Fair pavilion was now a
drawback for finding an appropriate post-Fair use. The Park soon became
home to derelicts and drug pushers. No one else came by anymore. In 1976,
the other major structure salvaged from the Fair, the Federal Pavilion,
was demolished because vandals had nearly destroyed that structure from
the inside out. That pavilion had never found a post-Fair use.
In 1977, lack of maintenance and the effect of wind
sway caused the panels of the suspended roof to become loose. After
several blew off and onto the Grand Central Parkway, the roof was ordered
removed from the structure. The cables left as a ghostly spider web.
The terrazzo map was now exposed completely to the
elements. Vandals picked away at it removing whole sections of New York
City and Long Island. Slowly the blue glass globes lining the outside of
the pavilion and towers and rails were broken by stones and rocks. Bird
droppings in the open stairwells caused whole sections of stairway to
disintegrate and break away so that climbing the stairs to re-lamp the
warning light at the top of the tallest tower that warns planes on
approach to LaGuardia became a rope climbing exercise.
Year after year after year the building sat and
deteriorated. Two major motion pictures, “The Wiz” and “Men in
Black,” used the pavilion as a setting. But once the camera crews were
gone, the cosmetic repairs to make the rusting old hulk look good in the
close-ups, disappeared along with the actors. The Parks Department applied
an occasional coat of paint to slow the rust and hide the deepening scars.
Today, to the naked eye, the pavilion is a disaster.
The lower level of the mezzanine is beginning to separate from the
building. Huge cracks run through the cinder-block walls. The elevator
towers are rusted. One “Sky-Streak” elevator sits smashed in the
service well at the base of the tall tower while the other has been
suspended in mid-air for 30 years. The vandals have even managed to scale
the tower far enough to smash in its windows and protective bars.
The steel crown at the top of the structure that
supports the suspension cables that support the roof is rusting badly.
Soon, the tension cables will begin to snap which could result in the
catastrophic failure of the entire crown.
The map is beyond repair. Parks Department personnel
have patched the missing terrazzo with concrete patches. The rest of the
terrazzo is as crazed as an old piece of porcelain. Weeds and plants grow
between the cracks and it seems every Spring an abandoned car is found
inside despite the chain-link and padlocks used to keep trespassers out.
The former Theaterama building was renovated several
years ago and serves as the Queens Theater in the Park. The New York State
Pavilion’s only role now is a storage shed for the Theater. Outside, the
curious stand looking up, shaking their heads in disgust.
But the real problem with Philip Johnson’s
pavilion cannot be seen. The problem that goes all the way back to 1933
and the creation of what would become Flushing Meadows Park. It is what is
going on underground and unseen that is most troublesome. Engineering
reports dating back to 1992 indicate that those old wooden piles are
deteriorating and deteriorating badly at that. Given that the ground the
building stands on is so precarious, those sixteen massive 100-foot tall
columns need all the support they can get. Geotechnical firms have
recommended, in 1992, 1996 and in 2001, that the structure either be
stabilized or demolished. To date, the City of New York and the Parks
Department have done nothing.
It has come to that for Philip Johnson’s building.
Recent estimates to stabilize the pavilion are in the $7 - $10 million
range. The pavilion has reached a crossroads. In order to justify that
type of expenditure, a use has to be found for the pavilion now. It would
help if an effort could be started to seek Landmark Status for the
pavilion. But simple safety concerns for the people who use the Park
demand that something more than Landmark Status must protect the pavilion
- and the public. Either money has to be found to stabilize it or it must
be demolished.
At the eleventh hour, someone has
come up with a plan for the pavilion. The proposal is to adapt the
original structure for use as the new Air & Space Museum. (For
details, please visit: http://www.nywf64.com/savenys03.2.html).
The plan is so obviously "right" that it's
surprising it hasn’t been proposed before. The plans have been presented
to the Parks Department and the Office of the President of the Borough of
Queens and have generated much interest. But along with those
presentations have come the warnings of dire consequences if the
stabilization problems are not addressed NOW. And the Parks Department,
like a sleeping giant, is waking up to the concerns. Will they act to save
the structure? Or will they simply be rid of it and all its problems?
The easy way out would be the demolition. But the
building IS worth saving. From an architectural standpoint. From a
historical standpoint. From a cultural standpoint. This
article is meant as a wake-up call to all those who would help to save the
pavilion. Contact Queens Borough and Parks Department representatives in
New York to budget money for its' stabilization. Putting pressure on the
deed-holders to save it is the only alternative to its certain demolition.
The pavilion is now a modern ruin. If action is not
taken soon, there won’t even be a modern ruin to enjoy.
For more information, please visit www.nywf64.com
and www.inch.com/~buehler/ruins/fair
Contact Frankie Campione at CREATE Architecture,
Planning, Design New York, NY. Email: FCampione@CreateAPD.com
Please support the efforts to save this
architectural landmark.